Hyper-CVAD/Imatinib Proves Superior to Hyper-CVAD Alone in
Philadelphia Chromosome-positive ALL
A
study from The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center that
evaluated long-term outcomes in Philadelphia chromosome-positive
acute lymphoblastic leukemia (Ph+ ALL) found that the combination
treatment of a hyper-CVAD regimen (cyclophosphamide, vincristine,
doxorubicin, dexamethasone) and imatinib has more benefits than
hyper-CVAD alone, according to results presented at the 2010 ASCO
Annual Meeting by Deborah Thomas, MD, Associate
Professor in the Department of Leukemia at M. D. Anderson. In
the study of 54 de novo or minimally treated patients with Ph+ ALL,
the 3-year rate of complete response duration for those receiving
hyper-CVAD plus imatinib was 68%, compared with 24% for a
historical cohort treated with hyper-CVAD alone (P
< .001). The combination regimen also resulted in
significantly improved overall survival of 54% at 3 years, compared
with 15% for hyper-CVAD.
"Ph+ ALL has historically been very difficult to treat, although
90% of patients achieve an initial complete response even with
traditional chemotherapy regimens-but long-term survival is only in
the region of 10% to 20%," said Farhad Ravandi,
MD, Associate Professor in the Department of Leukemia at
MD Anderson. Dr. Ravandi presented the data at the Best of ASCO
meeting in San Francisco.1

"The regimen of hyper-CVAD plus imatinib is very effective and
does improve outcomes, especially for patients who do not go on to
a stem cell transplant," he added.
Of 35 patients in the study who received imatinib and did not
proceed to an allogeneic stem cell transplant (aSCT) after complete
response, 10 are still in complete remission, he said. Yet Dr.
Ravandi noted that the study's long-term data suggest that aSCT
remains important for those who receive hyper-CVAD plus imatinib,
particularly for patients under age 40.
Study Design
The study included de novo and primary refractory imatinib-naive
Ph+ ALL patients as well as those who achieved a complete response
after one cycle of an alternative induction therapy without
imatinib. The regimen consisted of eight cycles of alternating
hyper-CVAD with methotrexate/cytarabine as well as 600 mg of
imatinib on days 1 to 14 of induction and continuously during
courses 2 through 8. Patients received 800 mg of imatinib (or best
tolerated dose) during 24 months of maintenance therapy with
monthly vincristine/prednisone interrupted by two intensifications
of hyper-CVAD plus imatinib, and then imatinib indefinitely.
Results were compared to a historical cohort of 50 patients treated
with hyper-CVAD without imatinib, also at MD Anderson.
Initial results after induction indicated that 36 (92%) of 39 de
novo patients achieved a complete response as well as 100% of 6
patients with primary refractory disease. Also, more patients
achieved a complete response after just one cycle of the imatinib
regimen (85%) compared to those who received hyper-CVAD (70%).
Subgroup Results
Although initial study data did not indicate a
benefit for aSCT in those who received imatinib, continued
follow-up revealed that patients who went on to stem cell
transplants experienced superior outcomes. When the investigators
looked at use of aSCT in de novo patients younger than age 60 who
received hyper-CVAD plus imatinib vs those in the same treatment
group who did not go on to aSCT, the trend favored stem cell
transplant-although the difference had not yet reached
significance. The 3-year overall survival rates for these patients
were 77% with aSCT vs 57% without aSCT (P = .1) When
the researchers compared patients on chemotherapy alone who went on
to aSCT vs those who did not, however, they found that patients in
the hyper-CVAD historical cohort derived more survival benefits
from stem cell transplant (P = .02).
Dr. Ravandi pointed out that the use of aSCT was particularly
beneficial for de novo patients under age 40 in first complete
remission after chemotherapy and imatinib. In this group, patients
treated with imatinib had a 3-year overall survival rate of 90%
with aSCT vs 33% without aSCT (P = .05). "It's very
significant that only 1 out of the 10 who got a transplant has
died, as opposed to 4 out of 6 patients who did not receive a
transplant," he said.
Patients over age 60 who received imatinib fared worse than
younger subjects because of the intensity of the regimen, Dr.
Ravandi said. Among 16 de novo patients under age 40, treatment
failed in 5, for instance, whereas among 13 patients over age 60,
treatment failed in 10. The investigators did not find that
persistence of BCR-ABL transcripts by quantitative polymerase chain
reaction (PCR) testing was predictive of relapse.
Other TKIs
Dr. Thomas noted that second- or later-generation tyrosine
kinase inhibitors used with hyper-CVAD might further improve
treatment outcomes for patients with Ph+ ALL.
In fact, researchers at MD Anderson are now studying the use of
dasatinib (Sprycel) combined with hyper-CVAD in patients with Ph+
ALL. In a recent phase II study of 35 previously untreated patients
with Ph+ ALL, published in Blood,2 Dr. Ravandi and
fellow researchers found that the dasatinib/chemotherapy regimen
achieved a 94% initial complete response rate. The median
disease-free survival and overall survival had not been reached
after 14 months, but the estimated 2-year survival rate was 64%.
Although the dasatinib regimen does not appear to produce improved
survival over one containing imatinib, Dr. Ravandi noted that 10%
of patients in the dasatinib study went on to aSCT in first
remission, compared with 20% of patients in the imatinib study
reported at the Annual Meeting.
"One could argue hypothetically that dasatinib may negate the
need for transplant in a subset of this population," Dr. Ravandi
said. ■
References
1. Thomas DA, O'Brien SM, Faderl S, et al: Long-term outcome
after hyper-CVAD and imatinib for de novo or minimally treated
Philadelphia chromosome-positive acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Best
of ASCO Annual Meeting San Francisco.
Abstract 6506. Presented July 17, 2010, by Farhad Ravandi,
MD.
2. Ravandi F, O'Brien S, Thomas D, et al: First report of phase
II study of dasatinib with hyper-CVAD for the frontline treatment
of patients with Philadelphia chromosome positive (Ph+) acute
lymphoblastic leukemia. B
lood. May 13, 2010 (epub ahead of print).